This is a really great product! I’ve tried other eyeliners because of hype and continue to run back to this one. The pencil lasts forever, glides on smoothly, is highly pigmented, and does not budge! It is definitely waterproof for me, and while I don’t swim with eyeliner on - it does not come off or smudge until I use actual eye makeup remover. It’s very comfortable on my water line as well as my eyelids and layers well with eyeshadows. I definitely feel this is worth the price for the amount of product and wear I am able to get out of this.

Application was easy. The formula is good but didn’t lasted it more than 4 hours for me. I have sensitive eyes when comes to eye makeup so I loved it. It’s waterproof. It didn’t smudge.

Love this product! It’s makes it so easy to draw a cat eye and also the sponge at the end is helpful for cleaning up any mistakes. It is also truly waterproof and does not move