I'd like to make it 3.5 stars for the record. I love the color, "Loveable," but it applies a bit chalky. For this reason, I tend to use it as a bit of a lip highlighter, on top of a base color. It works great this way and I think it's mostly due to the light, chalky hue. It could work on its on for a special occasion like a summer fun pop look. I liked it enough for awhile and then got into using another brand. Once in a while I'll use it. So, I likely won't buy it again, but it was good enough for a couple months. I love that it has a built in mirror!