I buy wetnwild products quite a bit because the for cheap price, the quality is usually amazing, but these color icon kohl liner pencils were terrible in every shade I bought including pretty in mink due to the dry formula. I have never experienced legit pain trying to smudge or rather drag across eyeliner on until I used these. They left my undereye so raw and red that I returned them the next day making sure they took what they had left on the shelf down to send back to the manufacturer. I don't know whether these were a bad batch or these just are horrible quality, so just to be on the safe side I don't be repurchasing rhese again because I already shuffle with sensitive eyes. I don't recommend these, but the rest of the wetnwild line is great.