I really wanted to love this eyeliner, and honestly, maybe I just got one from a bad batch, but I would not buy this again. I believe I purchased this eyeliner from a local drug store. Wet n Wild has really great prices for almost all of their items so it was just so effortless to buy because I felt like I wasn't losing out on too much.
I tried this with multiple styles and multiple products underneath. I tried this with/without primer, with/without eye-shadow, with/without face lotion, all by itself, etc and it ALWAYS smudged on me. If it got the slightest bit wet, it wouldn't dry for the rest of the day and I would play a waiting game of, "when is this going to start running down my face?"
This is not Summer proof. You cannot sweat with this unless you want to have two black waterfalls going down your face.
The WORST part about this eyeliner is, after a week of wearing it, I noticed chemical-like burns on both of my eyelids and near my outer eye where I make my "wing." It was very painful and once I stopped wearing the eyeliner, it was very dry but began to heal.
I tried the eyeliner once more while in a pinch (I ran out of eyeliner and had somewhere to attend) and the chemical burns returned again. I would not recommend this to anyone but this is just my personal experience.