It depends on your preference. If you mainly wear neutral colors and don't take too many risks (or aren't looking to try!), then the Naked palette is a great option. If you LOVE playing around with different colors and looks, the Vice palette would be the better option. Also, take a look at what you have already. While the Naked palette is great, it doesn't contain any colors that aren't incredibly uncommon, whereas with the Vice palette you're getting some great pigmented colors that you can't get from too many other brands.