i like this makeup remover but you do have to be a little aggressive for it to work correctly. Its a fine price, i have seen better and worse. It works pretty okay for all the facial products. I would probably not use it on lipstick because it just kinda smears and then stains the other parts of the face. I don't know how the proper way to apply it is but if you do it with cotton, its going to break the cotton apart, and i hate that! it works decently well, i would definitely repurchase it, but overall I'm more of a makeup wipe person so it would be cool if they had these in wipe form!