I love using the Ole Henriksen Pure Truth Melting cleansing gelee to remove my eye makeup, especially waterproof mascara and liner. I bought a .5 oz jar from Sephora for about $12 and it lasted me about 9 months. I use it every day buy dipping my finger in the jar, rubbing the gel over my closed eye and holding a cotton ball over it for 30 seconds. Swipe away the makeup then wash with your normal face cleanser. I have heard that this works with Johnsons baby lotion as well but I love the cleansing gel cause you can use it all over the face, even to remove liquid lipstick!