It’s a nice eye liner. Waterproof. But i didnt 100% like it. It smudges for me. I am not really an eye liner person so maybe i just dont know how to correctly apply it so…but i like that it has a sponge looking tip at the end to help with product application.

I always like to wear eye makeup especially eyeliner! Finding a good eyeliner can be a job sometimes until you find that perfect one. A friend recommended Thrive to me after I noticed how pretty her eye makeup looked! She said she only uses Thrive Causemetics. After hearing her rave about how great she liked it I wanted to try it too! So I went home and ordered from their website. All the reviews were amazing and none were really bad. After I got mine in the mail I was super excited to try it out. And I must say Yes she was right! This eyeliner worked wonders for opening up my eyes more. I apply mine to my top and bottom. And oh yea I was able to create a flawless winged look each time. It’s easy to apply, didn’t smudge or crease. Once applied it almost dried instantly. I like that it gave my eyes that pop of wow look that girls like me want in an eyeliner. Its very easy to remove without pulling at my lashes. I’m definitely recommending Thrive Causemetics as one of my top favorites to all my friends!

This product glides on great but it doesn’t stay put as well as I’d expect for the price. Color is really pretty I got the brown bronze shimmer color “nalie”. I think it goes really nicely with my brown eyes. This is one of the better eye pencils I’ve used. I think I’ll continue to liquid liner occasionally for bolder liner.