I prefer the Naked palette overall, but I was really impressed with Nude'tude! I think the color selection in Nude'tude isn't as great as Naked or Naked 2, plus I feel like the Naked's just have more product. I think it really comes down to budget. If you want to or can spend $50 on a palette, go for Naked. If you're on a budget, Nude'tude is a great alternative because you can snag it for $36 or even $18 during one of theBalm's 50% off sales. If you're super on a budget, Makeup Academy has exact dupes for the Naked palettes for 4 pounds each! It's a UK brand, but they ship to the US for around $10 - worth it for what you're saving! If you're interested, do a google for Makeup Academy's Undressed palettes vs Urban Decay's Naked palettes. There are tons of comparison review out there, and from all the swatches I've seen, the colors are almost an exact match. The Undressed palettes were definitely designed to be copies of the originals.