I have both and they are honestly both awesome! I love the tarte palette because it is mostly matte but includes a bit of shimmer if you want to change it up. However, the stila has a wider variety of colors. The pumpkin orange color is gorgeous! It also includes a beautiful dark plum that I keep using. So if you are die-hard matte only, get the Stila because it has more color variety. But with either palette, you won't be disappointed!