I like this eyeliner I only have the black one it doesn’t smeared. It’s waterproof.It looks amazing with a dramatic makeup look and a glam look . I would recommend this one one of my favorite eyeliner right now .

This is an ok products. I have very watery eyelids, this does not have a long wear to it. Not terrible just not a go to.

I bought the black one!! This is the best gel eyeliner I have ever had!! I recently my bf broke up with me and I was crying all night and my eyeliner didn’t come off that how waterproof it is!! 💕😍💕💕💕💕