This is my first time trying a lip plumper. I have to say it was very underwhelming. I do not like the smell of it. It doesn't plump them to the point that I'm like oh woooow I need another or I will recommend this to everyone. The colour of this one is nice as I love shades of brown on me. But I don't think I would buy the product again. It's not terribly priced but for it not working like everyone said it would i would save your money!