I had really high hopes for these removing wipes for when cleansed skin after a long night is near impossible. But despite the claims they truly just seem like overpriced all natural baby wipes to me. They do remove mascara and eyeliner quite well and fairly quickly and gently, and didn't bother my contact lenses at all. But they also drag it around the face if you wear a heavy or dramatic look with dark colors. All in all I give them a 3 because they work as they claim, only leaving skin with slightly sticky but yet clean feeling, but I am fairly sure an all natural baby wipe looms and smells and feels the exact same and though I've never used a baby wipe on my face, it probably works the same too! Disappointed to say the least for $15 I expected better.