I received this Caviar Lip Cream in Ruby from a beauty box subscription. It is a lovely vintage red shade that applies smoothly and opaquely. However, while your application might start perfectly with a defined lip line, it feathers quickly and starts running all over your face. It has a cream finish that does not seem to dry, so it did not survive a cup of coffee. After an hour or so, I found the color faded quickly and needed reapplication. Cannot recommend.