I came across this eyeliner when looking for natural eyeliners that weren't tested on animals. I have been using the Honeybee Gardens eyeliners, but decided to try something different since those are hard to find where I'm at. The SheaMoisture eyeliner was on a list I read and I had no idea they even made this product! It was only $6 so I figured I'd give it a try. I originally loved this stuff because it goes on smoothly and the color stays well. Unfortunately, it is extremely hard to sharpen and when I tried to sharpen it for the first time, it cut the whole liner over half! It never even sharpened to a point. It was like sharpening those cheap plastic pencils you got in elementary school. I won't buy this again simply because of this reason.