I love the packaging it's very pigmented the texture slides on like I like the texture and it's the pencil slides on perfectly like no issues at all for me it's a great value of money and I like the pigmentation it's really pigmented though it's the best value for money and I kind of do like this scent the scent like is I love my are kind of like the scent

SHANY dreamy dozen matte lip liner set is a phenomenal value. These are extremely affordable but highly pigmented long-lasting lip liners. You do have to sharpen them with a pencil sharpener. These lip liners last even through eating and drinking. They perform like a high-end lip liner. The colors are very diverse and work well with so many different lipsticks. That easily glides on with no tugging or breaking. I highly recommend them. I would definitely repurchase.

Very pigmented and great to use, they look amazing and don’t wear off easily, I definitely recommend and they colors are a good variety!! They make great combinations