I'm a big fan of this brand in general and their lip sleep mask is an absolute must have for me. I tried this liner and was not disappointed. It's one of the clean, vegan brands that are hot now, but I always get great results from Seraphine, unlike some of the other "clean" make up brands. This is a sample of how dark the liner is and honestly, this one is pretty old and might be ready to be thrown away. (I think I have a new one at home-this is in my to go bag!) You can't go wrong with this and it's only $18, which is a decent price!

I received this product in a BoxyCharm box and honestly forgot about it for a while. I just unwrapped it from the plastic sealant and used it for the very first time. Mt first impression was that it is a very watery formula and not very pigmented. My pictures are attempts to layer product but it just kind of felt like I was applying “water color.” I also applied it to my hand because after the initial application, the product wasn’t really coming out anymore. I would definitely not buy this, I’ll stick with my KVD tattoo liner

But not the best, went on smooth and easy to control, wish it was more black black , this is a softish black. Still will use till its gone though