Sephora Ultimate Gel Eyeliner in Brown Chocolate has its ups and downs. The pigmentation and durability score a 3/5 – it tends to smudge quite easily, especially without an eye primer. While the color is lovely, it might require a bit more effort to keep it in place throughout the day.

Terrible pencil that dragged and also kept crumbling and making it impossible to even attempt or make a wing! So dry and uncomfortable