Navneet S.
47 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3

Is this really comparable to Anastasia pencil? Has anyone tried both?

Karen R.
Karen R.
Twentynin Plm, CA
1 year, 10 months ago
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
I have used both, I first tried Anastasia because all the talk about it but I decided to try Sephora brand because it was half the price. I absolutely love it! It lasts longer during the day, is waterproof, and I feel the product lasts longer altogether. The Anastasia ran out so fast.
Olivia B.
Olivia B.
Los Angeles, CA
2 years, 1 month ago
I've tried both, and prefer the Sephora brand! It wears much longer than the Anastasia pencil, in my opinion. I found the Anastasia pencil smudged throughout the day.
Kathryn P.
Kathryn P.
Champaign, IL
2 years, 3 months ago
I have tried both! This one is definitely creamier so it's a little harder to get natural hairlike strokes. Also, even though it's not very much money, it only lasts me about half the time that the Anastasia eyebrow pencil lasts me.

Sign up to join our community!