These are beautiful eyeliners. The formula is creamy and applies smoothly. The colours are highly pigmented and look very foiled. They are not glittery or shimmery, but they are very illuminating and reflective. I have difficultly getting eyeliner to adhere to my waterline, and unfortunately, these pencils don’t stick. I really like these pencils and would recommend them to others. I am wearing the bronze coloured pencil in my lower water line in the attached picture.

The set is good especially for the price but I think the pink pencil is not pigmented enough to been seen on my skin. Two others are gorgeous gold and bronze. So pigmented and stay the whole day even on my water line. I would repurchase the set anyway because the price is great.

These eyeliners are beautiful! I love the color scheme and the quality. They go on easily, sharpen well and last all day. I get so many compliments when I wear these. I’m sad they’re a limited edition collaboration, I may buy a backup while I still can.