So I got the glittery black color. And it is kind of a grayish color more than black. Like a chalky look. So I didn’t think I would like it. But once I had it on I really liked it. It’s not dark at all. So if your looking for a really dark black waterproof. This is not it. But if your looking for something subtle.. yea this is it.it looks a little like a glue eyeliner.. if that makes sense. It’s actually not very water proof either.