So I’m still unsure about the product. I wanted to be unbiased so I’ll read other people’s thoughts after this. I love the color on myself even though I’m not use to wearing it. I bought the liner for my bottom lid. It was a bit hard to apply because it’s chunky, but it looked good. My issue is my eyes get so irritated from the liner it’s all liners I’ve tried (which is many). My eyes burn for the following day as well too.