This is a really nice product...my only concern is that it lists "fragrance" as one of its ingredients, and skin care really shouldn't have any added fragrances in it (Paula's choice has a great article on this). Im not sure exactly where the fragrance is derived from, but there are no other concerning ingredients listed (& fragrance free can be hard to find), so I'm willing to over look it. (Also, the scent is actually really nice, but since the toner is rose water based, I feel that it would still smell really nice without the added fragrance, only the smell would be fainter.) Other than that, it does add moisture and brightness as much as this type of product can and all of the other ingredients are really nice. I don't necessarily think that this product is a necessity, but it is nice and very fairly priced - you get a ton of product!