This is my perfect “my lips but better” color. It’s a pretty pinky mauve that runs a tad on the cool side. The actual texture is the perfect balance between waxy and creamy. In my experience, it’s leaps and bounds above their other line with the twist up pencils. This line however, has the perfect amount of pigment plus opacity so this works great on its own or in conjunction with other lip colors. It seems to melt into my lips making it comfortable and spreadable. It’s also never bled outside my lip line, wears comfortably, and keeps my other lip colors in place for longer. My one gripe is that a lot of the time the cap goes down too far causing it to squash the point. This is such a pain when you take it with you, given that this is a wooden pencil that has to be sharpened. Still, I would most definitely repurchase this!

It is very pigmented, and builds up easily. I haven’t needed to sharpen it in all the time I’ve had it. However from the moment I opened it, it’s had this waxy smell. Like a crayola crayon. It doesn’t go away while you wear it. It’s a good pencil, but I can’t stand the smell it makes me feel like a little kid colored on my face.

This is a terrific lip liner! It’s very creamy and smooth. Sometimes it smudges a bit for the most part it works well. I have the shade Coffee Bean which is brown with a red hue. It’s very beautiful and pigmented. I typically wear it with M.A.C Cosmetics Lipstick in Verve. Works really well together! Would get it again!

Honestly, I have no issues with this lip liner. It lasts just as long, if not longer than some of my high end lipsticks and other other products. The price is affordable and I am able to find colors to match all the lipsticks I have. It's a nice creamy texture that doesn't feel drying and I havent had any problems with blackheads around my lips like other cheaper drugstore lipliners. So I rate it at a 4. Very happy!

I like the formula of the lipsticks they’re great for lining and can use them to fill in lips as well, look matte and have good pigmentation. The only problem I have with them is that they cap sometimes smashes the lip liner and ruins the point. I very careful with the way I put the cap on but it moves all the way up on its own. If you could look past that I would recommend.

I believe this was the liner I got on clearance at my local Walmart in the shade pink punch. This is a fun coralie bright pink and the only thing I have like it. It's a crayon type liner meaning it's not a pencil and I find the pigmentation to be nice. I'm not sure what the regular price was but for the clearance price it's pretty good I need to try more Rimmel products

When I bought my Tarte 5 O’ Clock lipstick, I knew I wanted a matching lipliner. By sheer color matching at Walgreens, I found that the Rimmel Lip Liner in (I believe) Creme Brulee was the closest match. It looks EXACTLY like my Tarte lipstick—the color match is astounding. That alone had me living for this lipliner. After using it, I found myself layering it under most of my darker shade lipsticks or lighter ones I wanted to darken up. It has been fantastic. It glides on so smoothly and is very opaque. It doesn’t have that extremely matte aspect where you find the pencil tugging at your lips. I definitely plan on browsing their other shades in the future especially with its reasonable price point. It’s worth your try!

Coffee Bean is a shade I have tested and worn numerous times. I like it for sure and I will continu6to use it but not over my NYX liners. Thos formula is easy to apply on lips that have been pre-moisturized but you can not apply this to lips that aren't really smooth. Good for the price like the reddish brown color goes well with rosy nudes.

I love Rimmel lip liners! I’d say this particular pencil is comparable to MAC lip liners. I find I grab for my Rimmel & Milani pencils more than my more expensive ones. They work well, not too stiff but not too creamy either. Good color pay off. They don’t last for hours & hours on the lips, but for the price, it’s good enough! 💋

Inexpensive & can be found at mostly any drugstore! I love how they are creamy & pigmented. You can’t go wrong with the price either! They offer a variety of shades. They are also easy to sharpen & can be worn everyday:)