Honestly, I have no issues with this lip liner. It lasts just as long, if not longer than some of my high end lipsticks and other other products. The price is affordable and I am able to find colors to match all the lipsticks I have. It's a nice creamy texture that doesn't feel drying and I havent had any problems with blackheads around my lips like other cheaper drugstore lipliners. So I rate it at a 4. Very happy!

I believe this was the liner I got on clearance at my local Walmart in the shade pink punch. This is a fun coralie bright pink and the only thing I have like it. It's a crayon type liner meaning it's not a pencil and I find the pigmentation to be nice. I'm not sure what the regular price was but for the clearance price it's pretty good I need to try more Rimmel products

When I bought my Tarte 5 O’ Clock lipstick, I knew I wanted a matching lipliner. By sheer color matching at Walgreens, I found that the Rimmel Lip Liner in (I believe) Creme Brulee was the closest match. It looks EXACTLY like my Tarte lipstick—the color match is astounding. That alone had me living for this lipliner. After using it, I found myself layering it under most of my darker shade lipsticks or lighter ones I wanted to darken up. It has been fantastic. It glides on so smoothly and is very opaque. It doesn’t have that extremely matte aspect where you find the pencil tugging at your lips. I definitely plan on browsing their other shades in the future especially with its reasonable price point. It’s worth your try!

I love Rimmel lip liners! I’d say this particular pencil is comparable to MAC lip liners. I find I grab for my Rimmel & Milani pencils more than my more expensive ones. They work well, not too stiff but not too creamy either. Good color pay off. They don’t last for hours & hours on the lips, but for the price, it’s good enough! 💋

My go to affordable drug store liner. I’ve used tiramisu and spice. Spice is great for warm looks, and tiramisu is a versatile liner for all looks. It has to be sharpened but it’s reliable. It won’t crumble like automatic lip liners sometimes do. It’s soft, not scratchy. It does last, but is not food proof or beyond.

I liked this because it is cheap, but it is a little too firm. It also isn’t cruelty free so I haven’t used it since I went cruelty free. It is good for the price you pay, just not great in general. I would not recommend just because I only support cruelty free brands

Great product, great price. Rimmel color selection could be updated, but always affordable. Never been much of a lipstick girl, bright fun glosses changed the game and growing up with a grandmother that never left home without her lipstick and liner, now I get it.

Rimmel is one of my favorite drugstore brand and I think they make good quality lip products!! This is definitely one of them. Very light on the lips and color that I chose 1000kisses was pretty nice too! It is a very warm and natural color and didn't make the lips drying. The pencil itself is thick and feels good applying it. Even though frequent sharpening is needed and can be painful at times, it helps create a good definition to the lips. I am not a big fan of the scent though, however it doesn't bother me because the lip pencil itself is good!

These are my all time favorite liners and that’s a lot coming from me because I haven’t always been the biggest fan of Rimmel products. They last for SO long so that claim is definitely true and all the shades are stunning. They’re simple and light weight and they’re very easy to work with. They don’t smudge but they’re all not impossible to take off when you want to. I always have one with me in my purse! They really can amp up any look because there are so many shades to choose from. Love these and will always keep them in stock!

Cafe au lait is my favorite shade!! It’s really hard to get your hands on because it’s always sold out so if you see it in store grab one you won’t be disappointed!! Rimmel makes the best drug store lip liners in my opinion. They apply so easily. It doesn’t skip when you’re lining your lips with it.
These are a little bit more drying than the Exaggerate line but I don’t mind it at all.
And these also don’t twist up like the Exaggerate line. You have to sharpen these. But I don’t mind it at all.
Holy grail!!! Must try!!!