I purchased this lip liner at target with a really good coupon from Ibotta. I picked up the color Enchantment (070) and why I thought it was a pink nude I don't know. It is not. I love that it is retractable and has the slanted tip. It makes application and fill in a lot easier. It is a smooth formula that glides on nicely. One draw back is the tip will break off if you exert just a little too much pressure. Other than the fact that and the color I really like this liner. Rimmel Exaggerate Lip Liner

One of my least favorite Rimmel products. This color in particular is a very light nude that is just not flattering, but that’s my bad. This starts out as a pretty dry formula overall, but these always seem to dry up way faster than the 1000 kisses which makes it difficult to apply without it breaking and crumbling on your lips with the slightest pressure. It’s a waste of product. Plus, the shape of the top on the pencil is at an angle making it even more likely to break off. The convenience of it being a twist up doesn’t mean much when it’s constantly crumbling off. The color payoff is just not good so I would save yourself the hassle and stick with the 1000 Kisses formula.

I have the shade Rose Quartz and I love it! It's a nice lip liner for the price. The color is nice and it performs well on the lips. This pencil comes in many natural-looking shades. It's not AS creamy as other liners from more prestige brands, but it works well enough. It's pretty pigmented and doesn't smudge. It smells a lot like pencil shavings though. I would likely buy it again anyway! I often use it with Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in the shade Sugarcane.

I got this in the shade 018 Addiction. It is a beautiful brownish/mauve. It glides on so smooth, doesn’t pull on my lips and it’s very true to the color on the packaging. I also really like the slanted tip! It makes applying liner around the corners of the mouth so much easier! Also if you lean more towards mauve colored lippies this is the holy grail lip liner you need.

Okay the reason I didn't like this lip liner has a lot to do with my own personal preferences so please be aware. First of all, the color is just too bright. I usually don't mind brighter and more lively colors but this is like neon barbie orange. Secondly, there's specks of sparkles in there which I just don't understand why it was needed and I just don't like sparkly colors on the lips. Thirdly, the product is really dry and I've had it break off on me like 3-4 times one which is just annoying and makes it so I go through the product a lot faster than I am actually using. 
Some pros of the product is that it really stays on and stains your lips. I wouldn't say it's transfer proof but you'll definitely still see the color on your lips at the end of the day and it fades out pretty evenly. Also, retractable pen is always a plus.
Please try OTHER Rimmel exaggerate lip liners because they are really good, and it's just this particular color!

The formula of these screams more lipstick to me than lip liner. I don't want an extremely hard liner, but I also don't want a very creamy one either. This is a little too creamy for me. It has broken many times on me when I've gone to use it because it is so soft. I like the color, but the formula just isn't my jam. The only lip liners from my stash that really work well are the NYX suede liners. I still have yet to find another brand that has a good lip liner formula. 

I have 3 of these which weren’t listed here, but they are Pink A Punch, Peachy Beachy & You’re All Mine. I like these. They are nice and creamy & has good color payoff. My only one negative about this is whenever I use it, the tip always breaks off & I go in with a pretty light hand. So the product gets used up quickly. Other than that they are very good and get the job done just wish they make them more sturdier, idk.

I usually do not like automatic lip liners because they start getting hard and don’t app,y so easily but this goes on like butter. Sometimes, I’ll even apply it all over my lips because I love the Rapture shade so much. I usually use Mac lip liner pencils 95% of the time but if you’re looking for a cheaper option and need a drugstore brand, use this one! Colors are nice, easy to use and works really well!

As a lip color (or lipstick) it’s fine, nothing wrong with it. As a lip liner it’s a little too creamy for my taste, I like lip liners to stay on all day.. and the creamier they are the less they tend to last on the lips. Also, due to the slanted shape you can’t get a very precise line.

I love this lip liner! I love it so much that some days I completely fill in my lips and use it as a lipstick! The pigmentation is incredible and it stays on for a really long time. I can’t get over the fact that the cost of this is around $4 . I would definitely recommend this product!