I purchased this lip liner at target with a really good coupon from Ibotta. I picked up the color Enchantment (070) and why I thought it was a pink nude I don't know. It is not. I love that it is retractable and has the slanted tip. It makes application and fill in a lot easier. It is a smooth formula that glides on nicely. One draw back is the tip will break off if you exert just a little too much pressure. Other than the fact that and the color I really like this liner. Rimmel Exaggerate Lip Liner

The formula of these screams more lipstick to me than lip liner. I don't want an extremely hard liner, but I also don't want a very creamy one either. This is a little too creamy for me. It has broken many times on me when I've gone to use it because it is so soft. I like the color, but the formula just isn't my jam. The only lip liners from my stash that really work well are the NYX suede liners. I still have yet to find another brand that has a good lip liner formula. 

I have 3 of these which weren’t listed here, but they are Pink A Punch, Peachy Beachy & You’re All Mine. I like these. They are nice and creamy & has good color payoff. My only one negative about this is whenever I use it, the tip always breaks off & I go in with a pretty light hand. So the product gets used up quickly. Other than that they are very good and get the job done just wish they make them more sturdier, idk.

I usually do not like automatic lip liners because they start getting hard and don’t app,y so easily but this goes on like butter. Sometimes, I’ll even apply it all over my lips because I love the Rapture shade so much. I usually use Mac lip liner pencils 95% of the time but if you’re looking for a cheaper option and need a drugstore brand, use this one! Colors are nice, easy to use and works really well!

As a lip color (or lipstick) it’s fine, nothing wrong with it. As a lip liner it’s a little too creamy for my taste, I like lip liners to stay on all day.. and the creamier they are the less they tend to last on the lips. Also, due to the slanted shape you can’t get a very precise line.

This lip liner was just alright. The retractable factor and the slanted tip made it pretty easy to apply,and it wasn't really drying or anything. My big problem was that the slightest bit too much pressure would make the tip break off and then it would be hard to use. Other than that,it was fine. Decent color payoff. Easy to apply if you didn't use too much pressure. Rimmel Exaggerate Lip Liner

Great lip liners for the price. I have Red Diva and You’re All Mine(baby mauve pink). They go on smoothly and don’t tug too much with application. Can be a little too soft sometimes and break off, so don’t push down to hard. But other than that I really like them, and I plan to buy more colors.

I think they changed the color and formula for this lip liner. It used to be more of the baby pink variety but it's now a bit darker and more cherry colored in my opinion.

The liner itself breaks off and crumbles if you put too much pressure. 

It's nice for laying under a lip gloss. I would repurchase still! 

These lip liners are the best out there especially if you are looking for something affordable. They are super creamy, glide on the lips perfectly, and there is no sharpener needed. They are a twist up which makes life so much easier. I even use these pencils as my lipstick sometimes because the colors are so beautiful.

I loveeee this product. Its long lasting and finshing is amazing.I love this top most brand.This  is one of my favorites brands and with reasonable price.I bought this from macys,jcpenney,walmart stores and it is also available in other stores like Fred Meyer,target,walgreens many.......It gives soft texture on skin. I would definitely recommend this product and brand too.Its better to search for offers before buying.Have different shades of color for different skin tones.I like to visit above stores only to buy this and find offers.It gives fantastic look for party and for simple makeup also.I am kinda shopholic ;) so love to buy and try different products ,brands and shades.It would be too nice if there are some small samples to try before we buy.Shade is just awesome on my skin and hope for others too.It has smooth  texture.I would definitely buy More n more n more...I love trying new products and samples tooooooo.Its bestiest best product I have ever used...