I am genuinely surprised about how well this pencil works on me! With waterline pencils, my eyes either get irritated and the pigment ends up everywhere besides my waterline or it just fades away in 2 seconds. This color is very subtle in my bottom waterline but I like it. It still brightens my eyes and makes me look awake but there isn't a heavy nude line that makes it look like I tried too hard to look awake. For Rimmel, it was more expensive than I thought but I love it so far.