Some of these reviewers must not be using the same litter. This is the best litter I've used yet. It has the best of everything. It clumps very well, the scent is pleasant without being too strong, it's virtually dust-free, and the lightweight material makes me not loathe getting it at the store. It's very reasonably priced and for one cat I only need to add more litter or change it out every 2-3 weeks. I may never switch to any other kind.