I got these purina beyond dog snacks for free to try out for my honest review. I have a 10 month old treat snob on my hands and a drawer full of snubbed treats. Until now. I broke off a piece to give to my dog to try...and he LOVED IT!!! I love that not only is it grain free, but that its also got real apples in it (he LOVES apples!). These have not caused him any tummy "issues" like some other treats we have tried, so i feel really good giving these to him. We even shared some with our neighbors pit bull, and she LOVED them as well! I definitely recommend these!