I have tried every hard dog food, price no option, up to 27 dollars for a 2.5 pound bag. My Chihuahua is so picky. I usually mix steak or chicken, some water and hard food. Penny would pick out the meat and leave the dog food unless she was really hungry, but at 4.5 lbs, that's not often. That was until I found this food. Not only is this food healthy, and good priced, but my dog actually eats it! So now my dog likes a food that I can buy at Walmart, not just Pet Food Express or PetSmart, and it's such a good buy compared to that high end food not sold in "normal" stores. I love this product and no longer look for another food to try. It's been over a year since we tried new food and that's a long time, my dog is 10 years old and we tried new food at least 1 time a year or 6 months if she wouldn't eat the particular food at all, so I'm happy and Penny Lane is happy and gaining weight, a good thing, sometimes she weighs close to 5 lbs!