I'm so torn on this one. This was my first time using this classic and I used it for a month straight and had mixed feelings the entire time.
The good: it works. It really breaks down makeup effectively. It virtually melted off my makeup even mascara and all I needed was a wash cloth to swipe it off. And my skin was noticeably clearer and hydrated during the month of me using it.
The bad: I just don't personally love the texture of it. I'm typically more of an oil-cleanser or a balm cleanser gal. So using a cream-to-oil was a bit new to me. It was just a lot thicker than I was used to, so I used it with a traditional cleanser to top it off.
Bottom line, it was more a texture thing for me, hence my personal rating of 3 stars. That said, it's good, and I totally get why it's lasted this long and is loved by so many!