Am I mad at this product? No. But am I shocked by its efficacy? Also no. Physicians Formula is another awesome grocery store brand that is hypoallergenic and oil free so those of us "blessed" with oily skin won't feel like an oil slick when we use it, but personally this product seems to take the lack of oil and just substitute a lot of water. Which makes it hard to apply to a warm face. So leave time to "bake" onto the skin and make sure the area is well primed. I think the yellow idea to counteract the dark circles that we all get due to lack of sleep is fantastic but a thicker formula might be necessary, at least for me.