Leaving off a star because I just recently purchased and want to give it a good 4-6 weeks before giving it all five (if it calls for). I am loving this so far. I actually enjoy the smell (very baby powdery) as I don't look for "good smelling" skincare products because it's essentially medicine for your face - it doesn't need to smell good. It does leave my face a bit dry but I follow up with toner, serum, and my night cream. For reference my skin is acne prone oily/combo. I have recently given up all harsh, foaming cleansers after being enlightened about the damage they cause and really appreciate this being a gentle lathering cleanser. Can't wait to continue to use and see the results!