I love the smell and the formulation! Looks natural but also polished. One tube lasts forever

I found a Paul & Joe's lipgloss in "Sherbet" at Winners a while back. I hadn't tried the brand before, but the packaging caught my eye and I couldn't resist. The gloss itself is really nice - the formula isn't too sticky and the shade is pretty and subtle.

So, I have shade 4. It's a dupe to Fenty. 100%. I returned Fenty cause it didn't live up to the hype. It is a wet look gloss and the packaging is super pretty.