I’ve tried all the feet lotion. My original favorite was a brand that Bath & Body Works discontinued. I accidentally started trying natural shea butter (I don’t know if it is this brand or not, but just any natural shea butter will do- try VITACOST’s online store to find them) because we had purchased some to do some crafting projects and had leftovers. OMG! It is the only thing that keeps my heel and feet smooth and hydrated! I don’t think it is worth buying shea butter that isn’t natural just for good smells. Keep it simple!