Seasonal Oreos are sometimes hit or miss. This flavor is in the middle. Pros include the gimmick of it being a fall flavor and color and are different from the originals. Cons include the taste. While it is not horrible, it tastes very artificially made. I would say that there are healthier alternatives in the market. I would recommend for those who really love the taste of Pumpkin Spice, but I would not repurchase.