I got this one in Brick House and I do love the color its a red that isn't so bright it has tints of brown in it which i love because it neutralizes the red a lot and makes it less orange, perfect for fall and olive skin tones that red doesn't usually work with. My one complaint is that it claims to be water proof but everytime the center of my lips wears off and it starts to look gross after 3 hours or so. 

I do love this red orange color, it goes very nicely with with one of my victoria’s secret liquid lipsticks that is also an orange tone red. However one complaint I have is that it’s very stiff and not very smooth to apply so sometimes a little chunk comes off of the tip I use too much pressure. Other than that this product is great and affordable

This lip liner was not at all the nude I was expecting. Definitely more of a pinky nude which I personally am not a huge fan of. It was sadly not long lasting at all both in terms of wear and the product itself. I feel like it wears off so easily and ran out after only a few uses. I’m usually a huge fan of NYX but this wasn’t for me.

I own a couple of shades from this line and I will say the formula seems to vary from shade to shade. The nude shades and the red shade I have from this range are wonderfully pigmented and apply smoothly. However, I tried a darker more vampy shade from this range and it applied extremely patchy and I ended up having to throw it away. I gave it several tries and no matter what it applied very unevenly and looked super unflattering. I prefer the slim lip pencils from nyx only because I've never had an issue with any shades from that range.
I do think that it has great staying power and really helps other lip products layered over it to last longer. I do find these to be ever slightly more creamy feeling than the slim lip pencils but still not one I would say would wear comfortably for extended periods of time on their own.

I’m a huge NYX lover. They always deliver quality products at a fair price. These retractable lip pencils are great. I actually use some colors as both my lip liner and for my eyes. They always stay put all day, and the color payoff is 🔥NYX Retractable Lip Liner

Beautiful color. Goes great paired with my Violet Voss Matte Liquid Lipstick in shade tryst. The colors are almost exact. Stays on all day. Great price. I love the retractable packaging. Glides smooth. Beautiful nude shade.

I own several of these in different shades. They are great and very affordable. I like to line and color in my lips and then wear whatever lipstick on top. I feel it makes my lipstick last longer specially when wearing Nyx soft matte lip creams.

I love these. Very nice product for a reasonable price. I buy mostly these because they compact the the high end of not better. Nice colors easily applied no skipping. The twist up is my favorite but I also use the sharpen kind. I love both.

Nyx is always my favorite drugstore dupe company. They have superior quality for such a low price. I have several of their lip liners and I love them all. They’re smooth AND they have great color and they have longevity of wearing all day!

I have this lip liner in a lot of colors. Goes on smooth and stays on well. The tip is very fine, so you get a thin line. I like to use this one with a lot of nudes but not as much with my reds as I tend to like a more bold line with reds