I own a couple of shades from this line and I will say the formula seems to vary from shade to shade. The nude shades and the red shade I have from this range are wonderfully pigmented and apply smoothly. However, I tried a darker more vampy shade from this range and it applied extremely patchy and I ended up having to throw it away. I gave it several tries and no matter what it applied very unevenly and looked super unflattering. I prefer the slim lip pencils from nyx only because I've never had an issue with any shades from that range.
I do think that it has great staying power and really helps other lip products layered over it to last longer. I do find these to be ever slightly more creamy feeling than the slim lip pencils but still not one I would say would wear comfortably for extended periods of time on their own.

This lip liner has great color payoff and stays put throughout the day, even after eating or drinking.  I have one in red and one in a nude shade, which both blend pretty well to match with different lipsticks.  I also sometimes like to fill in my lips entirely with the nude one & it is really pretty on it's own!  My one issue would be that they can feel a little dry, but overall great!

I use this most of the time and I like how it wears and how it feels. There's a huge color selection which I appreciate and the fact that I don't have to sharpen it is a huge plus because I live a fast paced lifestyle and taking the time to sharpen my pencils I will get lazy like I'm sure we all do from Time to time and I get pencil shavings stuck in either my drawer or basket and it totally sucks to get those on your blenders by accident! ! So not having the fuss and it also being so cheap and work so well is why I keep going back for it.

I really like this lip liner! Mainly the fact that it glides on so easily and doesn’t skip or feel dry. I will definitely buy more colors because this is the only lip liner I’ve used that I didn’t shrug my shoulders at (although I haven’t used many). My only complaint is that it doesn’t last as long as I would like and can look/feel gritty sometimes.

NYX lip liners are wonderful! For one, the price point is fantastic, but they behave like a prestige brand that’s much more expensive. They have great staying power, hold your lipstick in place, and have a great variety of colors for whatever lipstick or stain you’re using. The retractable ones are my favorite because who likes to sharpen??

The NYX Retractable Lip Liner is the best drugstore lipliner I have ever tired. The liner just glides on your lips perfectly. It does not look overly dry and the color pay off is exactly the right amount for a lip liner. I have multiple colors in this product and I will always repurchase when I run out.

These lip liners are very creamy. They line your lips very easily and stay very well throughout the day. I also like that the packaging is a retractable liner instead of one you have to sharpen. Would recommend for sure.

I got rid of all of my lipliners because these are amazing and all i needed in my collection! I fall in love with these every time i wear them. They are easy to break, but if you use a light hand and make sure you’re not pressing to hard then they are super amazing. these are better than MAC ones.

I loveeee this product. Its long lasting and finshing is amazing.I love this top most brand.This  is one of my favorites brands and with reasonable price.I bought this from macys,jcpenney,walmart stores and it is also available in other stores like Fred Meyer,target,walgreens many.......It gives soft texture on skin. I would definitely recommend this product and brand too.Its better to search for offers before buying.Have different shades of color for different skin tones.I like to visit above stores only to buy this and find offers.It gives fantastic look for party and for simple makeup also.I am kinda shopholic ;) so love to buy and try different products ,brands and shades.It would be too nice if there are some small samples to try before we buy.Shade is just awesome on my skin and hope for others too.It has smooth  texture.I would definitely buy More n more n more...I love trying new products and samples tooooooo.Its bestiest best product I have ever used...

This lip pencil is pretty decent. The packaging is easy to use and the color is beautiful. However, I still find that my lipstick bleeds when I use these and I prefer other lipliners to this one. The price makes these worth it but if you are super picky with lipliner I would try another brand.