I truthfully do NOT find this as an equivalent dupe. Color wise maybe... I own both. The NYX one tends to solidify and want to fall apart as a chunk - as in, I can peel it off (which might be nice for a easy clean up). I've never had that issue with UD! UD tends to stick to skin much better and is still easily removed with a decent makeup remover. If you want the look for cheaper and don't mind flakiness it'll get you by.