My dog loves these, but she can get through one bone way too fast and have an upset stomach (diarrhea). But if she is being paced, she does just fine. However, my dog has white paws and our carpet is ivory. When she chews on these, she gets slobbery and some of these crumble on the carpet. Her paws would be orange, and so is our carpet. Fortunately, her paws are easy to clean and a few run throughs with the vacuum cleaned up the orange tinge from our carpet.