NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil uploaded by Barbara M.
NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
4 varieties available

NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil


4.1 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars52%
  • 4 Stars22%
  • 3 Stars10%
  • 2 Stars15%
  • 1 Star0%


N.Y.C. New York Color Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils are tear-proof, sweat-proof and swim-proof eyeliner pencils that are perfect for an active lifestyle. The waterproof formula provides long lasting coverage, so you don't have to re-apply during the day.

see more...

Top Questions See all 6 Q&A

  • Does this have too much sparkle? I love trying new colors! 1 Answers
  • How long does it last for3 Answers
NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Reviews (40)
Q&A (2)
Media (1)
Leave a Review
  • "The eyeliner impressed me. it stays long and so true that it's waterproof. I like the shade of the color and its quality. happy to receive this in my 1st box. the jingle voxbox2015" in 3 reviews
  • "Really good eye pencil and super affordable goes on black and lasts for a good few hours. and there 99¢ at Walmart :) " in 3 reviews
  • "I bought this one in white for my water line and it was very pigmented but it smugged and left white under my eye bags" in 3 reviews
⭐️Kelly⭐️ O.
P C Beach, FL
22 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1
Review for: Brown more...
I’m not a makeup snob so this cheap little pencil satisfies all my needs just fine. It goes on smooth and blends well where I need it to. The color is just right. I don’t have much to compare it to, but I do enjoy the product.
Alisia E.
235 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Brown more...
Used this as a cheap brow pencil before and was very creamy. Smudged easily and didn't last all day. It is very cheap so you do get what you pay for, would probably be better used as a waterline pencil
Kathy B.
86 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
This eyeliner was extremely cheap from my local Walmart! However, it's definitely not the best eyeliner you can buy. Whenever I need to sharpen the pencil, it breaks! so I can never get a good point on it. I have to sharpen it just a little until the pencil shows. Then when I use it, I have to use short lines or else it really tugs at my eyelids! Do-able for the price, but difficult to get the perfect look from this pencil.
April G.
Anoka, Mn
146 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Review for: Dark Brown more...
I received this in my #jinglevoxbox complimentary for testing purposes! Brown is not my color at all but I gave I a try anyways. I usually shy away from any eyeliner that isn't my cover girl kind but I LOVED this! It is not rough like a pencil eyeliner at all, it is very velvety soft and smooth! It glidded on my waterline with ease and the color wasn't the merky brown I expected but instead a very rich color with a subtle hint of shine. It really brought something to my blue eyes and I would love to try this in other colors. Washed off easily with water and a wash cloth.
Sarah P.
Bridgeport , NY
312 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
I have this pencil in 3 shades. Jet black, Dark brown and charcoal. I use these pencils daily. They apply nicely, last long and gives me the nice smudged look that I want. The dark brown works well on my eyebrows also. They are not great for a clean line that liquid liners give. Overall, they work for me, the colors are nice and for around a dollar, you get a good sized pencil. I recommend this product highly.
Erika L.
127 reviews
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
As some of the reviewers stated, it can be harsh on the skin. I notice that if you were to use this as an eyeliner there would be tugging. However, I feel like this product is most definitely more suited to be a good eyebrow pencil. I used this one for years and with a spooly brush to make the color appear more natural, you can have wonderful result.
Tracy G.
146 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
I had high hopes for this eyeliner. It went on dark like I wanted, was smooth when I apply on my lids and under my eyes but it always smears. It doesn't last all day and if I keep reapplying, I have to take a tissue and wipe around my eye because if I don't, it looks like I'm a raccoon! So sadly I have to say goodbye to this one.
April K.
15 reviews
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
This eyeliner is a good staple I keep coming back to time and time again. It's incredibly cheap, yet it goes on super dark and stays there all day and night, even though I stick it in my waterline and have a bad habit of rubbing my eyes. I literally do not understand why people use more expensive brands, when this works just fine.
Madeline H.
Houston, TX
88 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
Most of my eye pencils are NYC brand, and for a long time I was happy with them. However they smudge very easily and are so soft that they cake onto your eyebrows. I can put on very little in the morning and by lunch start to look like a racoon. Unless you like a very smudged look, I would suggest a higher quality product
C M.
Brooklyn, NY
184 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
Review for: Classic Brow Jet Black more...
I have this in jet black and plum and love them both. I always buy these because they are inexpensive and i never have a make up look without liner. On the black i usually have to burn the end to get that blacker then black color i want but not with this one
maria l.
26 reviews
How long does it last for
Christina s.
Harriman, TN
997 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
Does this have too much sparkle? I love trying new colors!

Sign up to join our community!

Influenster Cashback
We recorded your visit.
NYC Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

was opened in another window. If you made a purchase Cash Back will be automatically added to your Ebates account tomorrow.

Please confirm your email.
If you have an existing Ebates account, make sure to enter your Ebates email

6 characters minimum. Password must consist of letters, at least 1 number and 1 special character.