Surprising enough lasted. I would recommend this product it is budget friendly. Nice colors for different tones of skin

These are ok! They dont cost much so if you're on a budget they are good to get. I personally prefer wet n wild lipsticks over NYC. They do have some pretty shades and they dont make your lips dry. The container is plastic and cheap too

I don’t normally like nyc makeup bc the eyeshadow isn’t pigmented at all and doesn’t blend well, but this and their contouring kit both work really well! Super cheap and can usually buy at dollar store!