As a cheap and broke college kid, this is my go to liquid eyeliner. It's good enough to last through the school day, or long enough for pictures before an event, but this liner is not consistent in wear. If you're looking for just a bar eye liner with no wings, this is great, but if you make wings it will either begin to wear off or smudge. The brush is manageable if you have a steady hand, but can the bristles are slightly splayed out normally- you usually have to form it to a point by wiping off the excess.
It's matte black, and its pretty dark which is good, but it can take a while to dry and can transfer into the crease while wearing it. Honestly, I'm fine with using it, but I probably wouldn't recommend it to a friend. If you can afford a better one, just go for that.