N.Y.C. New York Color Eye Liner Pencil
3 varieties available

N.Y.C. New York Color Eye Liner Pencil


4.1 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars43%
  • 4 Stars33%
  • 3 Stars17%
  • 2 Stars5%
  • 1 Star2%


N.Y.C. New York Color Classic Brow & Liner Pencils allow you to line eyes and fill in brows. Perfect, salon quality eyebrow shaping with a natural, non-waxy finish. see more...

Top Questions See all 13 Q&A

N.Y.C. New York Color Eye Liner Pencil
N.Y.C. New York Color Eye Liner Pencil
Reviews (774)
Q&A (6)
Media (6)
Leave a Review
  • "N.Y.C. New York is my goto jet black liner pencil! N.Y.C. never let's you down! " in 78 reviews
  • "It is very affordable and does not need to be sharpened for every use unless you like to line your eyes with a pencil liner." in 2 reviews
  • "It has such a rich black color and it is one of the best eyeliners out there for the price." in 1 review
  • "You have to sharpen it every single time to get it sharp." in 1 review
  • "Totally love this eye liner it's cheap but sometimes when I sharpen it always have an empty on the bottom. " in 1 review
Sarah M.
880 reviews
Review for: Brow And #921A Jet Black more...
The store I went to stopped carrying the NYC glitter eyeliner pencil I liked so I bought this instead. This is an amazing pencil. It’s so black, it never smudges or transfers. It’s so affordable too. I don’t know if they make this anymore, but this is the best pencil liner I have tried from the drugstore!
Arielle W.
North Gouverneur
135 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Review for: Brow And #921A Jet Black more...
This is still the cheapest eyeliner pencil and still is one of the best for good color. From a person that uses other higher brand eyeliners, I never have a problem going back to NYC eyeliner. The color is black rich and easy to apply to the waterline of the eye. PErfect for what I need at a great price. 
Amanda D.
Clarksville, IN
139 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
I have You've got the power. I like the black on this pencil. Its creamy and you don't have to keep building the color to get it black. The blue is a nice compliment on the bottom waterlines for blue eyes. It made my blue eyes pop and look bigger. I like that I can sharpen to my preferred length and affordable.
Pamela R.
59 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1
I use this product often. Its affordable and long lasting. I love not having to pay a large price for such a great product. Reapplying through out the day is a must!
Nicole N.
Hopatcong, NJ
586 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
Review for: Other more...
I've had this liner for a really long time, I think that's because it's pretty awful, it's so hard, it actually kind of hurts my hand if I try and swatch it, so I can't really use it on my eye's, I don't recommend this liner at all
Victoria M.
Lewiston, ME
40 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Review for: Other more...
Super hard to apply. Had to apply it several times to have any kind of color show. Tried several colors and each time had the same results. If I hadn’t gotten them on sale I would have returned them.
Ashli J.
260 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
Review for: Brow And #921A Jet Black more...
The nyc eye liner pencil is a big NOPE! from me. The only thing good that I personally have to say about it is that it sharpens smoothly. The color wasn’t good, the pencil seemed waxy. It smeared, smudged, and pooled in my corners. And my eyes are sensitive so, I had itchy red swollen watery eyes all day. It may work for someone else but I personally can’t use this product.
Shannan M.
Windsor, PA
313 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Other more...
For a buck a pop these can't be beat. Very dark black and sharpens well without breaking. It is an old school hard liner but if you run it across your hand a little it'll warm it up enough that it goes on smooth. Or if you're like me, warm it with a lighter, just be sure to make sure it's cool before applying. 
Shalanda H.
49 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1
Review for: Brow And #921A Jet Black more...
Love how easy it is to put on. It stays on all day. The color is perfect. I use the black but planning to try the brown. I bought mines from Walmart and I also think Dollar General has it too. I use this product daily. I recommend this product and has given to people as a gift. 
Madison W.
12 reviews
Review for: Brow And #921A Jet Black more...
NYC products generally disappoint me. I usually never buy them unless I'm in a real bind. This eyeliner runs and leaves big circles around my eyes. And there is much to be improved. Maybe it was sitting on the shelf too long at the store? Because the one I purchased wouldn't give out any color because of see tye of dryness.
Yomayra C.
Providence , Ri
2 reviews
How good is this product??
Cherry M.
Golden Valley, MN
25 reviews
What, how is the best way to do you eyebrows? What's the best products to get the best eyebrows?
Brittany R.
83 reviews
Does this eye liner pencil apply correctly ?
Robin C.
N Hollywood, CA
4 reviews
I hate the eye liners that hurt when you put them on your lower lashes. Does this one go on dark or light? I also hate when trying to put it on and it tugs. Does this one glide smooth or tug at your eyes?
Daisy C.
3 reviews

Sign up to join our community!

Influenster Cashback
We recorded your visit.
N.Y.C. New York Color Eye Liner Pencil

was opened in another window. If you made a purchase Cash Back will be automatically added to your Ebates account tomorrow.

Please confirm your email.
If you have an existing Ebates account, make sure to enter your Ebates email

6 characters minimum. Password must consist of letters, at least 1 number and 1 special character.