Me and my mom both tried this mascara and didn't like it. It didn't irritate her eyes, but it certainly did mine. Right after I put it on, my eyes kept watering and just feeling uncomfortable. Also this product is not waterproof. It literally just dissolves away. I got into the shower and when I got out, there was none left on my lashes, but i got no color on my fingers or hands when washing my face. It literally just dissolved... I do not recommend this mascara, especially if your looking for something waterproof.