Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

NYC New York Color City Proof 24 HR Waterproof Mascara uploaded by susie Z.
NYC New York Color City Proof 24 HR Waterproof Mascara

NYC New York Color City Proof 24 HR Waterproof Mascara


2.1 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars0%
  • 4 Stars16%
  • 3 Stars24%
  • 2 Stars16%
  • 1 Star44%
2.12 / 5 based on 25 Reviews

Top Questions See all 2 Q&A

  • I have the 24 hr waterproof eyeliner and I love it... So May ques...3 Answers
  • Does this last all day? Will it flake away or is it a high qualit...3 Answers
NYC New York Color City Proof 24 HR Waterproof Mascara
NYC New York Color City Proof 24 HR Waterproof Mascara
Reviews (25)
Q&A (2)
Media (1)
Leave a Review
Payton W.
270 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
This mascara did not work very well for me and it dryer out very fast. I have green eyes. There is total room for improvement. It's easy to apply but it doesn't apply well for me. I don't recommend this, but nyc's loose powder is something to try!
Alana C.
773 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
I really hated this mascara. I've tested their other mascaras before and they were pretty average, but this one just sucks. Clumps terribly.. Feels dry.. Doesn't do anything to enhance my lashes (like giving them length, volume, etc.) although it's cheap.. Total waste of money. Seriously don't buy it. And 24 hours? No.
Ashley W.
216 reviews
One of the worst mascaras that I have had the displeasure of wear. I was in a pinch and needed a water proof mascara I forgot my wallet all I had was some change with me so I got it. The second I applied it I knew I was going to lose some eyelashes it was so thick it literally made my lashes feel heavy. It clumped up and make my lashes beyond spidery it was a mess. The second it touched water to got flakes and got in my eye every 2 seconds. I tired to was it off but even with hot water it wouldn't all come off. I tired eye makeup remover, coconut oil, and even extra Virgin olive oil. I tried really hard not to pull in my lashes because they are so brittle and this mascara tortured them for almost a month and a half I had spaces where there was no lashes because it cause so much breakage. Please don't buy its a waste of money and will only mess up your lashes!!!!
Jennifer S.
332 reviews
I don't like this mascara very much. It doesn't do anything to increase length or volume. It separates and darkens my lashes a little bit but that's about it. It also dries out extremely quickly, which I think is common with this brand. The mascara wand already comes inside the tube (many other brands package the wand and tube separately) and I think that dries out the mascara much more quickly. I'll use up the ones that I have (I bought a few of these during a 50% off sale) but I wouldn't buy this again. I can just spend a few more bucks and get a mascara that's better quality than this.
Alanna B.
25 reviews
Me and my mom both tried this mascara and didn't like it. It didn't irritate her eyes, but it certainly did mine. Right after I put it on, my eyes kept watering and just feeling uncomfortable. Also this product is not waterproof. It literally just dissolves away. I got into the shower and when I got out, there was none left on my lashes, but i got no color on my fingers or hands when washing my face. It literally just dissolved... I do not recommend this mascara, especially if your looking for something waterproof.
Frances S.
86 reviews
A very, very average mascara. For the formula, ease of application and cool color tube it receives three stars. It lasts on my eyes for about seven hours, which gets me through the work day. It will start to flake and smudge after that. I'm not mad at the product because it's so affordable.
Ajanae B.
Tampa, FL
16 reviews
This mascara is certainly not the highest quality. It flakes off. And although it is supposed to be waterproof, it will start coming off if it comes in contact with water. With that being said, it does the job and brings out my eyes and eyelashes in a way that looks natural. Also, I can't give it a horrible review considering that it is one of the lowest priced mascaras out there.
Bri R.
Russellville , AR
28 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
I use this as a freebie for my clients who need mascara however I use a different brush and it makes such a difference. I actually love this mascara as a top coat to thicken and waterproof mascara already applied.
Lacey K.
6 reviews
This stuff is awful. It's way too clumpy. It's very black but not waterproof at all. The wand it pretty simple. It lasted me about a month. My eye color is green. I would not recommend this to anyone.
Rheanna W.
181 reviews
I like the water proof aspect o this mascara but the downside is that it is really thin. Like it barely looks like I have anything on, so it kind of defeats the purpose of using any mascara.
Yanisa C.
Utica, NY
72 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
I have the 24 hr waterproof eyeliner and I love it... So May question is ,this mascara is the same quality like the eyeliner,what I mean it's 24hr also? Thank you
dana l.
31 reviews
Does this last all day? Will it flake away or is it a high quality mascara? Seems like a good price!

You came for the review, stay for the community. Over 25 million honest reviews from people like you.

Sign up now