Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
2 varieties available

NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner


4.2 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars51%
  • 4 Stars33%
  • 3 Stars12%
  • 2 Stars3%
  • 1 Star1%
4.29 / 5 based on 449 Reviews


Are you looking for an eyeliner that can keep up with your on-the-go lifestyle? NYC City Proof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner is the perfect solution for you! This multi-benefit pencil works overtime, so there is never a need to reapply. Just quickly glide on for long-lasting 24HR color!

Available to buy at Target.

see more...

Top Questions See all 66 Q&A

  • Is this automatic or do you need to sharpen 1 Answers
  • Is this long-lasting? I want it in hopes that I can tight...5 Answers
  • I was wondering if anyone else has had a problem with thi...3 Answers
NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
Reviews (449)
Q&A (19)
Media (218)
  • "This was very smooth eyeliner. Easy to use and super bold. It was truly waterproof and very tough to remove well. I did feel in smudge a lot. " in 84 reviews
  • "I found out about this product watching my favorite beauty YouTuber on Youtube. First I was skeptical about this eyeliner because of its price, but then another one of my favorite Youtuber mention that this is really an awesome eyeliner so I have finally went to store and bought it. I have tried so many eyeliner before and most of them smudge on me, it is kind of tricky for me to find the right eyeliner because I have oily lids so it was kind of a challenge every time I put on eyeliner. But this one is truly awesome product, it never smudge on my eyes, it didn't flake like most of cheaper or affordable eyeliner in the drugstore, it glides on and what I love most about this is it a matte finish and super black, I have a bigger and weird eyes and the shiny finish eyeliner never looks good me so I stay away from those type of eyeliner. This is my holy grail eyeliner so far." in 62 reviews
  • "Amazing product, glides on smoothly. Doesn't budge at all. Doesn't smudge or transfer onto the lid." in 33 reviews
  • "Love, love, love this eyeliner for the waterline. Went on super smoothly and lasted a really long time. " in 31 reviews
Rebecca C.
Highland, CA
22 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
I cannot find this local or online anymore.. went to
HaVasu in the summer and bought all 8 the store had in stock. It applies smoothly, leaves a great smooth line and lasts all day, even when rubbing your eye, you know we all do it! It’s not Cakey and is true black! Amazing eyeliner!
Autumn M.
193 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Black more...
 I usually use a liquid eyeliner, but I bought this because it looked like a soft tip. I was very disappointed. This is a cheaply made pencil. After a few uses the wood chipped off and into my eye. It was hard to sharpen too. The color also did smudge. I will just stick to my liquid.
Jamie S.
3 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1
Review for: Dark Brown more...
This eyeliner is the best! Literally stays put ALL day. Doesn’t leave a reside line after a few hours like most eyeliners out there. NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
Elizabeth C.
Greensboro, NC
329 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Review for: Black more...
I do believe I received this product free for testing purposes, at some point, in one of my Influenster VoxBoxes. It applies well and leaves me with a bold, black look that I love. It is waterproof and holds out well for all day wear.
Topaz S.
Parma, OH
78 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
Review for: Black more...
It's not amazing or anything but I do use it everyday
I only use it on my waterline because it doesn't have a sharp enough tip to put on my eyelid

It smudges a bit throughout the day but nothing too much
It does have a very opaque color and glides on super easily
A little tough to sharpen but it does work
Jennifer M.
Odessa, FL
1277 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
Review for: Black more...
I got this from amazon when my old eyeliner was running out. I am pleased at how smooth this applies and how well it goes on my lids. the color is pretty amazing and i like how it is waterproof which i need living in florida. this is amazing to use and smooth
Kristi C.
Catlettsburg , KY
76 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
I use this daily and couldn't be happier with this product! It stays on until you are ready for it to come off. Easy, smooth application. Make your lines as thin or as thick as you like. Very affordable!
Mariah K.
275 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
Received this in the Jingle VoxBox, all opinions are my own

This is the second NYC CityProof product I've received from Influenster and I'm still happy with the whole line. It's such an affordable brand and great quality for the price. I was skeptical about this eyeliner pencil at first, because I've never had great results with anything but gel + a layer of liquid. This one worked great! I don't know if I can say it's fully 24 hour of waterproof, but it doesn't smudge on my eyes and stays put for most of the day. I had it on from 8am to about 3pm before needing a touch up, but it wasn't a total mess and for a quick, everyday look it's definitely my new go-to. I added a layer of liquid liner on top to see if it lengthened the wear time and it definitely helped. All in all, a great product for a great price, but don't expect it to have high-end quality!
Savannah L.
Clarksville, TN
330 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Review for: Black more...
I love my NYC eyeliner. It doesn’t smudge or fade and lasts all day. It has a really smooth application. I also love that it is dark black. It really makes my eyes pop. It was very affordable. I would recommend this product.
Kasia L.
Boulder, CO
42 reviews
Hi I'm Kasia and I am an eyeliner addict... so I have pretty high standards when it comes to lining my eyes. I received this free in a VoxBox from Influenster.com a while back and it has quickly become my favorite pencil eyeliner. Applies so smoothly, very creamy but stays put all day even on my waterline. Very black and very matte. It took one use overtake my Sephora brand eyeliner pencil as my everyday liner and it's SO inexpensive that I can't imagine ever not owning one again. I even tried out a NARS liner yesterday and ended up going over it with this NYC liner because it's just simply better. I believe I owned one nail polish by NYC (which I've actually been enjoying for years) before discovering this product but it has certainly inspired me to further explore the brand. Highly recommend!
Nikki G.
31 reviews
Anyone having trouble sharpening theirs?
Katie L.
Edwardsville, IL
46 reviews
Is this long-lasting? I want it in hopes that I can tightline but I don't want to look like a raccoon by the end of the day.
Toni C.
Southfield , MI
21 reviews
How long does it last once you put it on?
Kristen A.
Fayetteville, TN
20 reviews
How long does this typically stay on? Usually when I use a pencil eye liner it doesn't stay on as long as a liquid!
Sahony B.
139 reviews
Does this eyeliner transfer ?

Sign up to join our community!



influenster cashback

Please confirm your email address.

6 characters minimum. Password must consist of letters, at least 1 number and 1 special character.

NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner
NYC New York Color
NYC Cityproof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner