Nars makes the best eyeliner, Period! And I've tried drugstore brands to high end brands. Has ideal "slip" for application and sets quickly and firmly. I have sparse eyelashes and wear the black eyeliner everyday for work. The pigment is rich, and when I apply in a smooth, thin line to my lashline, it really helps my lashes look thicker and my eyes have greater definition. Lasts all day. Black is my go-to! Amazing purchase!!