Reviews

I recently tried the Undone Beauty Multi-Dimensional Holographic Black Mascara, and unfortunately, my experience was not a positive one. While I was drawn in by the innovative concept of a holographic mascara that promises to elevate the classic black formula, the product ultimately fell flat. Firstly, the application was quite disappointing. The mascara had a thick, clumpy consistency that made it difficult to achieve an even coat on my lashes. Instead of the bold, defined look I was hoping for, I found my lashes were weighed down and stuck together, which is not ideal for anyone looking for a fluttery, voluminous effect. Even after multiple attempts, I was unable to achieve a sleek result. Moreover, the so-called "multi-dimensional holographic" effect was barely noticeable. Instead of a stunning iridescent shimmer, it felt more like a marketing gimmick than an actual enhancement. The holographic elements seemed lost when applied to my lashes and I found myself questioning if I really applied the mascara correctly at all. Another drawback was the wear time. After just a few hours, I noticed significant smudging under my eyes, which is not what you want from a mascara marketed to be long-lasting. Touching up throughout the day is a hassle, and I expected better performance given the brand’s reputation and price point. Lastly, the removal process was far from easy. I found that the mascara did not come off cleanly, leaving my lashes feeling brittle even after using a gentle makeup remover. This is a considerable downside, as the health of my lashes is incredibly important to me. In conclusion, the Undone Beauty Multi-Dimensional Holographic Black Mascara did not live up to my expectations. Between the clumpy application, lack of a noticeable holographic effect, poor wear, and difficult removal, I would sadly say this product did not meet my needs. I would recommend exploring other options if you're in search of a reliable mascara that truly delivers on its promises.

I'm a false eyelash girl. There I'll admit it. This didn't do much on falsies. I thought it was a fair price. This I would definitely target to the natural lash community.

I purchased this mascara at Ulta within the last couple weeks or so on sale seeing that it was from Undone Beauty which is a brand I have had good luck using another one of their mascaras that is oil free, which is helpful for my milia (skin condition I sometimes have along my upper left lashline) to not grow or become aggravated somehow which can happen and has happened for me in the past with oily eyeliners and mascaras. The wand is relatively simple and although it is the traditional type of wand with non silicone bristles which is generally not my preference, this one somehow seemed to be an exception to my tastes on that, possibly because the spaces between bristles/hairs of the wand were wide or large enough to still allow for good separation and definition to my lashes. I find that the formula for this mascara is also very good for lengthening, as well as even helping to hold a curl in your lashes. I like the 'holographic' effect of this mascara and find it interesting although personally, I would describe it as more like metallic than holographic per se, up close. I purchased mine for $10 at Ulta and given that the ingredients are healthy and this is itself an oil free mascara as well, I have enjoyed using it so far and feel it is a mascara I would be happy to recommend for others to give a try if some of the characteristics above are things they tend to look for or be happy about in their mascara products. 👁️ ✨

This mascara does nothing to my lashes except coats them and makes it sticky. My bottom and top lashes would stick together when I blink. It does not dry fast. Possibly one of the worst mascaras I’ve ever tried. It’s a shame cos I enjoy the brand’s face makeup products.

I'm really disappointed. I was so excited to try this brand and got a small kit with bronzer and lip gloss included. All products felt weak to me and the quality might be on par with products you'd find for kids makeup. The mascara, goes on beautiful but does not take long to fall off all over your face. I was hoping this brand would work for a quick minimal makeup day but it just doesn't for me.

this mascara was so unique. the little holographic flecks added such a nice touch to my lashes. loved this product!

I usually don’t write 1 star reviews but this mascara was very disappointing. It clumps my lashes (even worse than the better than sex mascara) and flakes throughout the day. I also don’t notice any lengthening or volumizing. The texture of this mascara is very strange, its almost “watery”. The ingredient is also a bit concerning. It contains alcohol which shouldn’t be used in “clean” makeup products.

This is one of my new favorite mascaras. I love the way it makes my lashes look, it lengthens and also adds volume to them. I it gives dimension to the look that the mascara is not just flat black. I also love the packaging, I think it’s very unique for a drug store mascara.

Nice mascara in terms of all-natural products. I usually find natural mascaras to be very flaky for me (like Pixi and W3ll People), but I experienced no flake with this one. The color very subtly shifts in the light to show some sparkle. Over all, this behaved more like a washable lash tint than a more firm-hold mascara for me

I really wanted to like this more, but it disappointed me. The gold flecks in it didn’t show up on my lashes at all. There was no sparkle, no catching of light. And I really didn’t notice any lengthening or volumizing either. Wouldn’t repurchase.