I got their "Loganberry Beautiful" dress for 50% off during their Black Friday sale. I wore it to the Homecoming dance and loved it! It fit me perfectly, and it was classy, modest, and made me feel like a classic Hollywood star!
My 'Paper Lantern Dress' It's no longer available on the site but it was my first purchase, a beautiful cream colored dress with the single most interesting skirt. A close second is the coat I purchased myself this past winter, 'The Importance of Being Onyx Coat'. The names they come up with are priceless.
I bought a lime green 50's-style circle-skirt dress with white trim and polka-dots, a sweetheart neckline and a white belt. It's my favorite dress in my entire closet, and I receive so many compliments on it!
I have quite a few favorite dresses that I've bought from ModCloth
But this green, sailboat, 50s style Emily and Finn dress is always makes me feel absolutely goregous when I wear it. :D