These are decent treats, my dogs like them, but then again my dogs like almost anything they can eat. I have two 55 pound dogs, but I give them these minis at various times throughout the day, because they get many treats and their regular food. Even though my dogs are trained. They usually get a treat for going to the bathroom outside, or as a reward for other tasks. given the fact that they get many treats and are getting older -- I do not like to feed them the larger treats because I do not want them to gain weight and put stress on their joints-- smaller treats equal fewer calories, I mix these up with different meat treats and another brand of small treats so they are not getting the same thing every time. They like these but they do not get as excited as they do with some other kinds of treats, very occasionally my female dog will not take these. All in all they are not bad and are available in a variety of sizes and flavors, and can be purchased almost anywhere.