let me start off by saying I have a little pug who can be very very picky. There have been some treats she used to be in love with, and than decided on the spur of the moment that she hated or wouldn't touch any longer. With these, she is in LOVE. They are a healthy alternative for a treat, and my pug goes nuts over them. She will literally listen to anything for one of these treats, and she is a stubborn little thing. At times when I need to get her to eat her food and she is refusing I sprinkle one of these on top once I crumble it and she will finish everything. I recommend these for sure, and am so surprised they have no reviews!