It definitely depends what type of look your aiming for. I own both mascaras and I love them both equally, but for different reasons. On days where I'm going for a natural makeup look, I reach for Mega Plush because it separates and elongates the lashes while still looking nice and natural. For a more dramatic look, I think Falsies is perfect. Falsies makes your lashes look long, dark and thick to give the illusion of a false lash almost. Hope this helps!